Cotter’s Garage has been serving the Saint Marys, Ridgway, Johnsonburg, and Kersey areas since 1934. Family owned and operated for over 85 years, we have gained trust from our friends in Emporium, Brockway, and all the surrounding areas. Our Elk County customers have a worry free, affordable, enjoyable car buying experience, and so should you! It is worth the drive from Jefferson, McKean, or Clarion counties. From the vehicles we offer to the service we provide, you can always count on premier quality at Cotter’s.

We carry only the finest quality late model vehicles, and if you don’t see it, just ask! We will be happy to find it for you. If you a prefer a Jeep, Ford, or Subaru just let us know. We are not restricted to any brand, make, or model making it easier for us to find what suits your needs. If you would like a Chevy or GMC truck, or maybe a Buick, Toyota, or Honda SUV, we always have new arrivals often, so just check back with us!

Voted Best in Elk County 3 years in a row!

Special thanks to everyone that voted for Cotter’s Garage! We greatly appreciate the support from our community.

With so much employee turnover in the industry, you may notice a difference at Cotter’s. Our employees have been with us for years! Our customers know we take the worry out of buying a used car or truck by offering honest sales and service. We love to take care of our customers because we live here too! We will see you at the schools, at church, or at a local restaurant, and know that a friendly hello is coming our way. You can be sure that we care about you and your car, and of course our community.

Thank you for voting Cotter’s Garage Best of Elk County 3 years in a row!